Missing the Point About Aurora…
Public discussion and debate about the Aurora, Colo., horror has missed the point. With numbing predictability, liberal opinion leaders in the press have focused on gun laws as the potential solution for such atrocities, while conservatives have responded that maniacs will find ways to kill people and therefore, nothing can be done about rampage shootings. Others have speculated that our excessively violent entertainments are tipping borderline types into spasms of real violence.
I’m no fan of degraded entertainment, yet I suspect that saturation media coverage of these events is probably more culpable. But surely a more fruitful avenue of inquiry concerns our utterly dysfunctional mental health system. We don’t know much about the killer in Colorado yet, but in many cases of rampage shootings, family members, colleagues or teachers saw signs of trouble before the eruption of violence. Family reports of disturbing behavior are often not enough because too many state laws require that a person be “imminently dangerous” before he can be involuntarily committed — even for a short time. Thus, we have failed utterly to protect those in dire need of treatment and also placed society at increased risk from the minority of mentally ill people who are dangerous.
For years, mental health authorities assured us that the mentally ill were no more dangerous than the average person. That’s true of most, but not all. As Dr. E. Fuller Torrey documents in his essential book, “The Insanity Offense,” rates of violence among the untreated mentally ill are significantly higher than among the general population and are also much higher than among those receiving medication. Between 5 and 10 percent of the untreated seriously mentally ill will commit violent crimes in any given year, accounting for at least 5 percent of homicides in the United States (a huge percentage in a nation of more than 300 million). For rampage crimes, such as the Aurora attack, the percentage of mentally ill perpetrators is much greater, as high as 50 percent.
Since the 1960s, when deinstitutionalization became intellectually fashionable and fiscally alluring to states looking to save money, the mentally ill have been dumped onto the streets. Today 95 percent of the in-patient beds that were available for psychiatric patients in 1955 are gone. The Treatment Advocacy Center explains that, “The consequences of the severe shortage of public psychiatric beds include increased homelessness; the incarceration of mentally ill individuals in jails and prisons; emergency rooms being overrun with patients waiting for a psychiatric bed; and an increase in violent behavior, including homicides, in communities across the nation.” Imagine if we treated the mentally retarded this way.
In many cases of mental illness…….
- Can The Mentally Ill Get Treated Fairly? (infinitesadnessorhope.wordpress.com)
- The Evil That Men Do – James Holmes, Aurora Colorado and Mental Illness (goodmenproject.com)
- A Dark Night in Aurora Colorado (spiritualmysticism.wordpress.com)
- The Aurora Rampage: Facing the Real Consequences (crooksandliars.com)
- Conquering Benign Paternalism (madinamerica.com)
- Blaming the mentally ill for violence is bad public policy as well as just plain misguided (beyondmeds.com)
- Mass murderers often not mentally ill, but seeking revenge, experts say (vitals.nbcnews.com)
- Summer heat and mental illness: A dangerous combination (al.com)
- Demands that it be easier to involuntarily commit the mentally ill are knee-jerk and irrational (beyondmeds.com)
- Robert David Jaffee: Calling for an Executive Order Banning Assault Weapons (huffingtonpost.com)