The true right to secede comes from God, not the Constitution

By Alan Keyes


In an article I saw this week at WND, Pat Buchanan writes of the Declaration of Independence:


The declaration was signed by 56 angry old white guys who had had enough of what the Cousins were doing to them. In seceding from the mother country, these patriots put their lives, fortunes and honor on the line.



GyGRet (Photo credit: GunnyG1345)


Four score and five years later, 11 states invoked the same right “to dissolve the political bands” of the Union and form a new nation. After 620,000 had perished, the issue of a state’s right to secede was settled at Appomattox. If that right had existed, it no longer did.



I have no idea why Buchanan refers to the signers as “old.” The mean average age of the men who signed the Declaration was 44.5. The oldest signer was Benjamin Franklin at 70 (though given his personality his colleagues, and the ladies at the Court of France, would probably have pegged it considerably lower). The youngest signers were Thomas Lynch Jr. and Edward Rutledge, at 26. Nearly two-thirds of the signers were in their 30’s or 40’s. Unless he accepts the silly notion that anyone over thirty is old (even less true today than when it was in vogue back in the 60’s), calling the signers “old men” leaves rather a false impression.



gophum (Photo credit: GunnyG1345)


Not being a leftist, or one of the dubiously self-professed “conservatives” who regrets the outcome of the War between the States, I see no reason even subtly to denigrate the physical or mental acuity of the people who signed the Declaration. Yet I can’t agree with Buchanan that the right to secede was settled at Appomattox. Buchanan’s statement to that effect reflects the inadequate thinking that results when people use the word “right” as though it’s synonymous with “freedom.” Every right is a use of freedom; but not every use of freedom is a right. The distinction rests on whether the use of freedom satisfies or violates the standard that justifies the assertion of right.


People with sufficient power may successfully use it to enslave others. But given the self-evident truths set out in the Declaration of Independence, such use of their freedom violates the standard of right which impelled the people of the United States “to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them.” The Civil War was therefore not about the right to secede. It was about whether some of the States, frustrated in their efforts to compel the others to enforce and extend their wrongdoing, should be allowed violently to disrupt and attack the government justly ordained and established by the consent of the whole people of the United States, including their own.


President Lincoln clearly anticipated war. But he carefully refrained from authorizing any military initiative against the Confederacy until a facility of the Constitutional government came under violent attack. He then acted to suppress armed insurrection against the Constitutionally-established government of the United States. This was Constitutionally his duty as President of the United States.


Lincoln’s restraint demonstrated his understanding of the issue at stake in the Civil War. In light of that understanding, the outcome of the war did not decide the issue of a state’s right to secede, because the Confederate States were not exercising a right. They were engaged in wrongdoing. Their actions were wrong in principle (i.e., according to the Declaration’s principles of God-endowed justice); and in terms of the U.S. Constitution. The latter requires the President, by oath, to “preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States.” It nowhere requires or authorizes the States (or any of their officers) to use force to attack the Constitutionally-established government of the United States.


This does not mean that there is no right to secede. It means that secession involves an issue of right that cannot be decided under the U.S. Constitution……




via The true right to secede comes from God, not the Constitution.





Enhanced by Zemanta

About Gunny G

GnySgt USMC (Ret.) 1952--'72 PC: History, Poly-Tiks, Military, Stories, Controversial, Unusual, Humorous, etc.... "Simplify...y'know!"
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

38 Responses to The true right to secede comes from God, not the Constitution

  1. Pingback: Charles Krauthammer The President Wants to Create a “Civil War” in the House… (Gunny G: And, As Usual, The “Reader Responses” Are As Good Or Better Than The Article!) « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG & EMAIL

  2. Pingback: How U.S. Economic Warfare Provoked Japan’s Attack on Pearl Harbor – Robert Higgs – Mises Daily « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG & EMAIL

  3. Pingback: Gunny G: What “The Folks” Are Wondering ‘Bout??? ~ What Justice will swear in 0bama on Jan. 20 2013 « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG & EMAIL

  4. Pingback: Robert F. Kennedy Jr: Fox News Has Divided America In a Way Not Seen Since the Civil War « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG & EMAIL


  6. Pingback: Half of America: I’d kill to protect my own… (“50 percent expect that within two weeks of a catastrophic emergency, their home, person or family member would be physically attacked by someone desperate for food, money or commodities like



  9. Pingback: U.S. Constitution Created an Empire « Blog « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG & EMAIL

  10. Pingback: Pat Buchanan: Why the War Party Fears Hagel « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  11. Pingback: The U.S. Constitution: ‘A Mere Thing of Wax’ « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  12. Pingback: Why Would A Black Man Wanna Fly A Confederate Flag?!? « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  13. Pingback: Hundreds sign up to live in the Citadel – an armed fortress community planned for Idaho « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  14. Pingback: Obama 2.0: Smarter, tougher — but wiser? (by David Gergen) « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  15. Pingback: Govt Insider: Obama Livid; 2nd Amendment, Liberty & The American People Won Today | Obama « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  16. Pingback: Bugging Out vs. Hunkering Down….. « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  17. Pingback: A Voluntary Federation ( Lincoln was Wrong ) « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  18. Pingback: Obama’s inauguration speech morphs liberty into tyranny « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  19. Pingback: How The South Will Rise To Power Again « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  20. Pingback: Lincoln and the Copperheads… « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  21. Pingback: Devvy Kidd — How the GOP committed political suicide in 1982 « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  22. Pingback: Amnesty = EXTINCTION for GOP [GOP Going Out of Business] « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  23. Pingback: Why is government stockpiling guns, ammo? … “These words – “civilian national security force” – have haunted me ever since I first read them.Obama has never explained what he meant. He’s never been called to account for that remark.D

  24. Pingback: The U.S. Constitution: The 18th Century Patriot Act « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  25. Pingback: The Men Who Destroyed the Constitution by Thomas DiLorenzo « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  26. Pingback: Constitution Worship Revisited: I’m Still Fed Up…! by Gary D. Barnett… “I always wonder not only have any of these people ever read and studied the constitution, but also do they even understand why it was secretly drafted in the first

  27. Pingback: Thomas Sowell: ‘AT WHAT PRICE?’ – The Difference Between Liberals and Conservatives « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL


  29. Pingback: TV AD: Imperial President – YouTube « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  30. Pingback: Ron Paul Warns Immigration ‘Reform’ Will Turn The US Into A Police State « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  31. Pingback: Indigestion – Fix It! by Margaret Durst « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  32. Pingback: 5 Reasons 2/23/2013 is Going to Be a Day of Resistance « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  33. Pingback: (NC) Sheriff: Gun permit applicants required to release mental health records « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  34. Pingback: Prepare For The Coming Cyber Wars: US Government To Launch Pre-Emptive Cyber Strikes (Prepping) « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  35. Pingback: Death 0f America: Leaked US Army Document Outlines Plan for Re-Education Camps in America Video | Politics « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  36. Pingback: Why We Must Defend Our Founding Documents………… “I’ve got a simple idea: Let’s give up on the Constitution. . . . This is our country. We live in it, and we have a right to the kind of country we want.” « AMERIC

  37. Pingback: Panetta: Obama Absent Night of Benghazi… “In fact, Panetta says that the night of 9/11, he did not communicate with a single person at the White House. The attack resulted in the deaths of four Americans, including Ambassador Chris Stevens.

  38. Pingback: All the President’s Drones: Don’t reprove the drone war, improve it. « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

Comments are closed.