The Daily Bell – Jettison the Constitution?

Let’s Give Up on the Constitution … As the nation teeters at the edge of fiscal chaos, observers are reaching the conclusion that the American system of government is broken. But almost no one blames the culprit: our insistence on obedience to the Constitution, with all its archaic, idiosyncratic and downright evil provisions …

RPREVOLU

RPREVOLU (Photo credit: GunnyG1345)

Our obsession with the Constitution has saddled us with a dysfunctional political system, kept us from debating the merits of divisive issues and inflamed our public discourse. Instead of arguing about what is to be done, we argue about what James Madison might have wanted done 225 years ago. – New York Times

Dominant Social Theme: We need a new approach and strong leaders.

Free-Market Analysis: Our trends for 2013 featured the advance of German-style National Socialism in the US, and this probably qualifies along those lines.

gophum

gophum (Photo credit: GunnyG1345)

The Times article unapologetically makes the argument for doing away with the US Constitution but what is to be substituted and how it is to work is not made clear.

The argument itself is an obvious one, especially as hardly a shred of the so-called Constitution remains, in any case. The Supreme Court routinely defies it, Congress ignores it and the executive branch simply steps around it as necessary.

One can even make the argument that the Constitution was a big step backward from Articles of Confederation that somehow were seen as not “strong enough” for a growing nation. Nonetheless, the Constitution – an entirely illegitimate document within the context of its creation – was launched out of a legislative conference that gathered under strict orders NOT to draft a new document.

As usual, Alexander Hamilton – a man who believed in a strong federal state – was one of the biggest backers of the document, which was purposefully written in a vague way apparently and was in many ways authoritarian in scope simply because it left so much not clarified. The final document created such an uproar that a “Bill of Rights” was finally attached to strengthen it.

The author of this OpEd in the Times has a meaningful point when considered from this vantage point. Louis Michael Seidman is a professor of constitutional law and he has studied the US’s dysfunctional Constitution and simply advises that we scrap the document. Here’s some more from the article:

Consider, for example, the assertion by the Senate minority leader last week that the House could not take up a plan by Senate Democrats to extend tax cuts on households making $250,000 or less because the Constitution requires that revenue measures originate in the lower chamber. Why should anyone care? Why should a lame-duck House, 27 members of which were defeated for re-election, have a stranglehold on our economy? Why does a grotesquely malapportioned Senate get to decide the nation’s fate?

As someone who has taught constitutional law for almost 40 years, I am ashamed it took me so long to see how bizarre all this is. Imagine that after careful study a government official — say, the president or one of the party leaders in Congress — reaches a considered judgment that a particular course of action is best for the country. Suddenly, someone bursts into the room with new information: a group of white propertied men who have been dead for two centuries, knew nothing of our present situation, acted illegally under existing law and thought it was fine to own slaves might have disagreed with this course of action. Is it even remotely rational that the official should change his or her mind because of this divination?

Constitutional disobedience may seem radical, but it is as old as the Republic. In fact, the Constitution itself was born of constitutional disobedience. When George Washington and the other framers went to Philadelphia in 1787, they were instructed to suggest amendments to the Articles of Confederation, which would have had to be ratified by the legislatures of all 13 states. Instead, in violation of their mandate, they abandoned the Articles, wrote a new Constitution and provided that it would take effect after ratification by only nine states, and by conventions in those states rather than the state legislatures.

This is what we meant when we wrote above that the Constitution was created via an illegitimate process. What is usually even less discussed than the illegitimacy of the Constitution is WHY those who created this document acted the way they did. Some would submit that the Constitution was simply a way for European banking powers to begin the process of re-establishing control over “these States.”…….

EXCERPT!!!!!

via The Daily Bell – Jettison the Constitution?.

IS THIS MAN, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF...

IS THIS MAN, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, THE LEADER OF THE FREE WORLD, MENTALLY ILL? (Photo credit: SS&SS)

Enhanced by Zemanta

About Gunny G

GnySgt USMC (Ret.) 1952--'72 PC: History, Poly-Tiks, Military, Stories, Controversial, Unusual, Humorous, etc.... "Simplify...y'know!"
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

39 Responses to The Daily Bell – Jettison the Constitution?

  1. Pingback: Obama may Ignore the Debt Ceiling and Suspend the Constitution: Obama and the Debt Ceiling « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  2. Pingback: (“They encouraged the manufacture and importation of deadly military firearms for the criminal element to use. This was intended to foster a feeling of insecurity which would lead the American people to voluntarily disarm themselves by passing laws

  3. Pingback: (“They encouraged the manufacture and importation of deadly military firearms for the criminal element to use. This was intended to foster a feeling of insecurity which would lead the American people to voluntarily disarm themselves by passing laws

  4. Pingback: Kill The Constitution – Professor Drafts OP-ED Against Document – Judge Andrew Napolitano – YouTube « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  5. Pingback: The Founders had a chance to discuss Progressivism, and they rejected it « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  6. Pingback: “WHAT IS THE CONSTITUTIONAL LAW OF TAKING AN OATH OR AFFIRMATION AND BEING BOUND BY OATH OR AFFIRMATION?” ~ EDRIVERA.COM – United States America Organic Law Taxes Property Jurisdiction Constitution : EDRIVERA.COM « AMERICAN BLOGGER

  7. Pingback: “WHAT IS THE CONSTITUTIONAL LAW OF TAKING AN OATH OR AFFIRMATION AND BEING BOUND BY OATH OR AFFIRMATION?” ~ EDRIVERA.COM – United States America Organic Law Taxes Property Jurisdiction Constitution : EDRIVERA.COM « AMERICAN BLOGGER

  8. Pingback: The Daily Bell – Axiom 3: Back to the Articles of Confederation as America’s Central Government « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  9. Pingback: The Daily Bell – Axiom 3: Back to the Articles of Confederation as America’s Central Government (Gunny G: The Solution To THE PROBLEM???) « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  10. Pingback: The Constitution: The God That Failed (To Liberate Us From Big Government) by William Buppert « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  11. Pingback: Devvy Kidd — How the GOP committed political suicide in 1982 « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  12. Pingback: Conservatism Is Dead « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  13. Pingback: Amnesty = EXTINCTION for GOP [GOP Going Out of Business] « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  14. Pingback: Why is government stockpiling guns, ammo? … “These words – “civilian national security force” – have haunted me ever since I first read them.Obama has never explained what he meant. He’s never been called to account for that remark.D

  15. Pingback: The U.S. Constitution: The 18th Century Patriot Act « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  16. Pingback: The Men Who Destroyed the Constitution by Thomas DiLorenzo « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  17. Pingback: Constitution Worship Revisited: I’m Still Fed Up…! by Gary D. Barnett… “I always wonder not only have any of these people ever read and studied the constitution, but also do they even understand why it was secretly drafted in the first

  18. Pingback: Thomas Sowell: ‘AT WHAT PRICE?’ – The Difference Between Liberals and Conservatives « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  19. Pingback: When America Went Crazy by Eric Peters « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  20. Pingback: TV AD: Imperial President – YouTube « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  21. Pingback: Ron Paul Warns Immigration ‘Reform’ Will Turn The US Into A Police State « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  22. Pingback: 5 Reasons 2/23/2013 is Going to Be a Day of Resistance « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  23. Pingback: (NC) Sheriff: Gun permit applicants required to release mental health records « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  24. Pingback: Gunny G: ALTERNATE NON-PC NEWS UPDATED 24/7 HERE !!!!! « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  25. Pingback: Prepare For The Coming Cyber Wars: US Government To Launch Pre-Emptive Cyber Strikes (Prepping) « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  26. Pingback: Death 0f America: Leaked US Army Document Outlines Plan for Re-Education Camps in America Video | Politics « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  27. Pingback: Dr Ed Rivera Law and Government ~ pt.1 – YouTube « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  28. Pingback: Panetta: Obama Absent Night of Benghazi… “In fact, Panetta says that the night of 9/11, he did not communicate with a single person at the White House. The attack resulted in the deaths of four Americans, including Ambassador Chris Stevens.

  29. Pingback: All the President’s Drones: Don’t reprove the drone war, improve it. « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  30. Pingback: (See Reader Responses…) ~ Administration’s New Climate Report: Next Ice Age ‘Has Now Been Delayed Indefinitely’ « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  31. Pingback: Senator Long calls for a constitutional convention « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  32. Pingback: DHS Insider: Obama’s cyber warriors & preparing for collapse « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  33. Pingback: Gunny G: Back Where We Came From Is Where We Oughta Go….. « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  34. Pingback: GUNNY G: THEY SOLD US A “BILL OF GOODS” WITH THE NEW ONE (It Doesn’t Work) THE OLD ONE IS JUST WHAT WE’VE ALWAYS NEEDED – DO THE RIGHT THING !!!!!! « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  35. Pingback: Lew Rockwell on the Constitution vs. Articles of Confederation….. | Peace . Gold . Liberty « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  36. Pingback: Articles of Confederation Reality Check | Peace . Gold . Liberty « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  37. Pingback: (Excerpt) HOW GEORGE WASHINGTON AVOIDED BEING BOUND TO THE WRITTEN CONSTITUTION – EDRIVERA.COM : EDRIVERA.COM « AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  38. Pingback: SCOTUS Employees Caught withholding legal documents from Supreme Court Justices | AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

  39. Pingback: Forget Guns…How About More ‘Congress Control’? (GyG: How Bout Back To Our First Constitution, The Articles of Confederation !!!!!) | AMERICAN BLOGGER: GUNNY.G ~ WEBLOG.EMAIL

Comments are closed.