The Great Civil War Lie…

The Great Civil War Lie

NY Times Disunion ^ | June 5, 2013 | MARC-WILLIAM PALEN

Posted on Tuesday, June 11, 2013 7:48:08 AM by iowamark

Civil War buffs have long speculated about how different the war might have been if only the Confederacy had won formal recognition from Britain. But few recognize how close that came to happening — and how much pro-Southern sympathy in Britain was built on a lie…

Early British support for the South was further buttressed by something as mundane as a protective tariff — the Morrill Tariff — approved by Congress on March 2, 1861. This new tariff, passed to protect American infant industries, also unwittingly gave rise to a troublesome myth of mounting trans-Atlantic proportions.

ourAmerica

ourAmerica (Photo credit: GunnyG1345)

The tariff had been opposed by many Southern legislators, which is why it passed so easily once their states seceded. But this coincidence of timing fed a mistaken inversion of causation among the sympathetic British public – secession allowed the tariff to pass, but many in Britain thought that the tariff had come first, and so incensed the Southern states that they left the union.

Nor was this a simple misunderstanding. Pro-Southern business interests and journalists fed the myth that the war was over trade, not slavery – the better to win over people who might be appalled at siding with slave owners against the forces of abolition…

gophum

gophum (Photo credit: GunnyG1345)

Why was England so susceptible to this fiction? For one thing, the Union did not immediately declare itself on a crusade for abolition at the war’s outset. Instead, Northern politicians cited vague notions of “union” – which could easily sound like an effort to put a noble gloss on a crass commercial dispute.

 

 

 

 

(Excerpt) Read more at opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com …

via The Great Civil War Lie.

isthisman

isthisman (Photo credit: GunnyG1345)

 

Enhanced by Zemanta

About Gunny G

GnySgt USMC (Ret.) 1952--'72 PC: History, Poly-Tiks, Military, Stories, Controversial, Unusual, Humorous, etc.... "Simplify...y'know!"
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

44 Responses to The Great Civil War Lie…

  1. Gunny G says:

    Re Europe’s Plan To Save The South, Parts !&2…

    http://dsreif.blogspot.com/2011/12/napoleon-pope-and-csa-part-ii.html

    Dick G
    *****

  2. Pingback: Let’s Destroy The “Cops Want Gun Control” Myth Once And For All – Part 1 | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  3. Pingback: Caught on the reef… “The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution reads:…But, what do we do when government sees the people as the potential enemy. Governments are no more than people aligned by ideology. They see enemies behind every a

  4. Pingback: Main Core: A List Of Millions Of Americans That Will Be Subject To Detention During Martial Law… | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  5. Pingback: Turning America Into Gaza… “Many Americans are waking up thanks to the alternative news now provided accurately for the first time by the worldwide Internet. The Internet is a tool that is now being used to cut through the lies of the US Gover

  6. Pingback: Talks of Secession Begin Among Several Colorado Counties following New Gun and Energy Bills (VIDEO)… ““They treat us as if we don’t exist,” he said. “It’s not like we didn’t try to engage the legislature — it’s that we were ign

  7. Pingback: Alan Stang: POPULATION EXTERMINATION… HOW WILL IT BE DONE? | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  8. Pingback: George Takei Fears NSA Spying Will Lead to Something Much Worse… “George Takei is hardly the only American concerned about the NSA’s massive surveillance programs. But unlike most people, his fears are rooted in the memory of the governm

  9. Pingback: The Demonization Machine Cranks Up Against Edward Snowden… “It’s always instructive to see who quickly takes the government’s side in a dispute with a whistleblower, and what kind of argumentation they deploy. David Brooks was cert

  10. Pingback: GyG: FREEPER CANTEEN: What Font Are You? | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  11. Pingback: GUNNY G: SOME RANDOM OLD GyG LINKS !!!!! | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  12. Pingback: High Profiling Doug Hagmann against NSA… “And he’s been told by a credible security source that an active investigation file has been opened against him by NSA” | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  13. Pingback: ***** ‘I’m neither a traitor nor a hero… I’m an American’: NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden.. ***** | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  14. Pingback: Snowden’ Second Interview: “I Am Not Here To Hide From Justice; I Am Here To Reveal Criminality” | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  15. Pingback: Sen. Ted Cruz On Being Obamaphobic For Opposing Amnesty: “Guilty As Charged” … “Well, it appears the Socialists just stick to the Alinsky playbook and believe that calling names will be enough to win the day. I suppose they didn’t get th

  16. Pingback: Why Things Will Get Worse — Much Worse… “…It is easy to be upset about what is happening all around. The economy is being destroyed, deliberately, by insane…rewards are increasing for not working. Not surprisingly we get less of

  17. Pingback: “Satan Has A Plan For Your Life” (Video/Vlog)… “The hand full of conservatives who have the integrity to fight the treachery will not convince the other 400 congressmen, the other 97 senators, the pretend news media and the 70% of American

  18. Pingback: The History of America’s Secret Wars: Corporate Espionage and the Outsourcing of National Security | Global Research | NOW BLOG THIS! ~ GUNNY.G: AMERICAN !

  19. Pingback: Riots by Fred Reed…. “Let’s not kid ourselves. Race underlies almost everything in this country that spends half its time denouncing racism. This is true of trials, and particularly true of show trials. When the police who beat Rodney King,

  20. Pingback: What Americans Used To Know About the Declaration of Independence by Thomas DiLorenzo | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! ~ GUNNY G'S... SINCE 1997

  21. Pingback: Abandon the United Nations?….. “It’s ineffectual, it’s corrupt, it’s unelected, it’s dominated by scores of tiny countries which have learned that if they claim discrimination or claim that their “human rights” are being denied, th

  22. Pingback: Remembering Mary Surratt; Marylander and Southerner | Dick.Gaines.American! ~ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  23. Pingback: 71% say the signers of the declaration of independence would be disappointed……. – BlackListedNews.com | Dick.Gaines.American! ~ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  24. Pingback: Dead Home Invaders Send a Message – “In Houston on Sunday afternoon, three armed men entered a home and demanded payment. They got payment. The owner of the home grabbed his gun, shot two of them dead, and scared off the third, who ran. This is th

  25. Pingback: Fred On Everything | Dick.Gaines.AMERICAN! ~ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  26. Pingback: Fox News Analyst (The Judge) Stands Up For Sen. Paul’s Secessionist Aide | TPM LiveWire | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! ~ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  27. Pingback: Should Civil War re-enactments be abandoned? | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! ~ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  28. Pingback: Today’s Toons 7/12/13 | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! ~ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  29. Pingback: Zimmerman Lawyers Were Once Supporters Of Judge Who Has Knocked Them About Florida Courtroom | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! ~ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  30. Pingback: Who’s Responsible for the 1861-65 Bloodbath? –….. | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! ~ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  31. Pingback: Stoking racial unrest in a headline… ” Poised like squabbling vultures, the American mainstream media reported almost gleefully on the predicted protests that would follow the ‘Not Guilty’ verdict in the George Zimmerman trial.” | DI

  32. Pingback: Population Cleansing Wars… | Veterans Today | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! @ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  33. Pingback: Searching for what’s still made in the USA… “Not all Americans are made in America any more.” | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! @ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  34. Pingback: Rand Paul Defends ‘Embarrassed’ Aide With Neo-Confederate Past… “Paul said in an interview with the Huffington Post. “If I thought he was a white supremacist, he would be fired immediately. If I thought he would treat anybody on the colo

  35. Pingback: Chuck Hagel warns: Troops are ‘close to the breaking point’….. | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! @ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  36. Pingback: The US Is a Failed State –… “America is a very sick patient with a curable cancer that, if left alone, will cause death. The cancer is the Union or the state known as the U.S.A. More commonly, the Union and the U.S.A. are referred to as the

  37. Pingback: Report: Hillary Clinton didn’t know Abedin would voice support for Weiner… “…Abedin did not consult with Clinton — who herself has grappled with a politician husband publicly straying — before stepping in front of the microphon

  38. Pingback: America’s scariest police chief shoots “libtards” and forms militias… | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! @ Gunny G's... Since 1997

  39. Pingback: Secession, Five Years Later –….. “Obama conceded defeat in an indirect fashion after assumption of his lifelong appointment at the circus-like Constitutional Convention in the USSR in 2012. The massive government intervention and adoption of

  40. Pingback: Gunny G: What The Folks Are Saing/NOT Saying ‘Bout…..Concerned Enough To Act… ????? | DICK.GAINES.AMERICAN! @ Gunny G's...Online Since 1997

  41. Pingback: Col David Hackworth Ret Calls Rumsfeld An ‘Asshole’ The War According To David Hackworth… “”Pistols suck,” wrote one soldier. “Bring and use every weapon. Shotguns are great at close ranges.” At a time when

  42. Pingback: The Re-Education Of The US Military… “These last few words in quotation marks were taken from a recent essay by the candid Irving Kristol (the neoconservative patriarch and patronus and former Trotskyite) who has for some years been writing ab

  43. Pingback: You Want Answers On Benghazi? Here’s the Truth….. “The Benghazi attack that resulted in the deaths of 4 Americans was, with almost 100% certainty, a planned prisoner exchange to swap Ambassador Chris Stevens for “The Blind Sheik.” It was

Comments are closed.